Look what we found in the bottom of the freezer! Not a bad find when searching to satisfy a sweet craving… but the best-by date was in 2014! Yes, today is 3/22/2021 – which means this cake was in the freezer for at least 7 years!.

If you’ve been reading our pages, you must have come across the term “freezing is an indefinite form of storage” a time or two. Since we believe in practicing what we preach, let’s take a closer look at this freshly defrosted cake.

frozen cake

Does a Freezer Really Keep Foods Indefinitely?

Freezing is an indefinite form of storage, meaning that some things may last as long as the freezer itself and others will fare much longer than elsewhere but will expire or go bad at some future point in time. Back to the cake at hand: Opening the sealed box, we found that the internal foil packaging was still completely and tightly sealed. We knew that this cake had been in the freezer and frozen the entire time since purchase. These facts gave us confidence in proceeding to put the indefinite storage concept to further test with this cake.

The date is clearly visible on this product and I have to say the best-by date of “03 03 2014” made some of our testers resist partaking in this test, but we continued. We carefully checked the packaging and it was completely sealed, we opened it up and gave it a very careful look over. Amazingly, there was not even a single trace of freezer burn – which is the tell-tale sign of something either not being sealed well or being left in the freezer for an over-extended period.

frozen cake

Next we checked the ingredient list and there were no quick to spoil items that would cause concern. Actually, there was one ingredient that was especially working on our side. Alcohol is a natural preservative that helps to inhibit the growth of bacteria. Freezing also does this, but the fact that this cake was also armed with internal alcohol gave extra security of a desired result.

Since all of the above conditions passed the test, we proceeded with giving it the sniff test. Nothing off here. Check, check, check – so our bravest testers dug into a slice.

Expired Cake Results

It was actually pretty good! It was both moist and flavorful. There was no freezer taste at all. If you didn’t look at the box and notice the best-by date, you may not know the difference from the original cake.

Conclusion
Do not expect any cake to last this long in the freezer. This brand of cake is vacuum sealed (which will always make a product last longer until opened) and contains alcohol (a natural preservative). The box on this product also further protects the cake from moisture. A homemade or store bought cake that is wrapped at home and then frozen will most likely pick up other flavors from the freezer and become less desirable after about 4 months in the freezer. See the additional information section below for more information on storing cakes.

Additional Information

To find out how long different cakes last, see our cake page.

For more information on freezing times, see our freezing post.

For help with organizing a freezer, see our organize a freezer post.

For help with organizing a refrigerator, see our tips to keep food fresh.

To find out how long other foods are good for, please visit the Dairy, Drinks, Fruits, Grains, Proteins, Vegetables and Other sections of Eat By Date or use the search function below.

SEARCH Eat By Date

Our Favorite Food Storage Set!

With oven-safe glass and water-tight lids, these food storage containers are ready for action! Not a Prime Member? Try a 30-day free trial today!

SHOP NOW

From The Blog

Top 10 Most Popular (NEW)

▶Kale
▶Deli Meat
▶Beer
▶Wine
▶Sweet Potatoes
▶Figs
▶Bacon
▶Hard Cheese
▶Pumpkin
▶Dry Ice